Perfectly Disgraceful
I had not spoken to Dana in five years when I received a message on my answering machine a few months into the new millennium. “Jules! Hey! Long time no see! I—[here followed a pause of two and a half seconds]—was just calling to say. Things are. I’m not sure if you want. But I could use. Anyway. Give me a call if you feel like it.” She left her ten-digit phone number with an area code of 757. I looked it up on my computer and discovered it belonged to the Southeast Region and Eastern Shore of Virginia.
I rewound the message and played it again. Her voice was ebullient at the start and then tapered off into uncertainty. I should give her a call if I felt like it, she said. Her tone, by the end, suggested she thought I probably wouldn’t. I wrote down the number in the notebook I kept next to the phone for such purposes.
“You’re not going to call her back,” my husband said that night after the kids were in bed.
I hadn’t been sure whether to tell him about Dana. Those five years of silence had been the end of our friendship, as far as he was concerned.
“I might,” I said. “I don’t know.” We were watching television, and a commercial break had come on. That meant the conversation wouldn’t go on too long.
“Jules, come on. You’ve been down this road.”
The way he saw it, this road was one of those narrow rural highways that snaked through the woods and made you carsick with its ups and downs. Brian was a big believer in taking the interstate.
“She might be better now. She might have grown up.”
“Or she’s exactly the same, only older. Which makes it worse.”
Worse could have meant a lot of things. Brian had long known Dana as my flaky friend. He’d also been the one to point out, years before, that she had a drinking problem.
“I just think there must be some reason she’s decided to get back in contact after so long.”
Brian reached into the bowl for another handful of popcorn. “That’s the best argument against calling her back.”
The ads still played. I didn’t have anything else to say, so I watched them on mute. Then the show came back on with its familiar setting and characters. Brian took the remote and turned up the sound. We watched the episode until the end and then he said, as if we’d been talking all this time, “We’re at that point of our lives now when you’ve got to understand that not everyone is going to make it.”
“Jesus, Brian.”
He looked at me as he chewed. “At some point the merry-go-round stops being fun.”
But the thing about Dana was just that: she was fun. I’ll always remember her bursting into our dorm room at two a.m., smelling of cloves, a feather boa wound around her neck like a scarf. “Mac ’n cheese!” she’d declare, laughing, and drag me out of bed to the kitchen down the hall, where she taught me compound nouns in German while we waited for the water to boil.
Other nights, sober, she would lie crosswise in the armchair we’d wrestled up four flights of stairs and read poetry aloud. “Stop studying and listen to this,” she’d demand. Once, she read a Frank O’Hara poem to me that included the line “I have been to lots of parties and acted perfectly disgraceful,” which she later wrote on the whiteboard hanging on our dorm room door. After that, and for the rest of sophomore year, we always had a line of poetry written on that board. We tried to change it every day or two.
I began reading poetry just to have something to offer. From Anne Sexton: “I have gone out, a possessed witch, haunting the black air, braver at night”—written on our board at the start of a weekend. I thought it sounded cool. Made me sound cool. Because the thing about me was I wasn’t all that fun, but I still wanted to be.
By the time I received Dana’s message on my answering machine, it had been many years since I’d read a poem not written for children. My kids were six and eight years old. We had entered that pivotal stage when both were in school and I was trying to figure out what to do with myself. I’d quit my job eight years earlier without a long-term plan in place and now felt as if I didn’t know whether to move forward or back. And so, one morning when my kids were in the yard playing with the neighbors, I dialed the number written in the notebook. A machine picked up and a man’s voice said he was sorry he had missed my call, but if I left my name and number, he’d be sure to call back.
I left a message and hung up while I watched my son. He was sitting off to one side of the lawn, running his hand over the grass. He wasn’t playing with the neighbors. He never did. I wasn’t sure yet if this would be his personality forever or if it was just taking him a while to figure out how the world worked. My sister-in-law Laurie had once told me that the hardest thing to do as a mother was to listen to your child when they were sad. To not try to solve their problems. Just listen.
I’d always thought I was a good listener but was starting to think that I wasn’t, not if listening meant what Laurie said it did.
To read the rest of this story, please purchase a copy of Issue #21 or to make sure you never miss a thing, subscribe to the print edition.
